Best Automatic Pool Cleaner

Article Contents

Pool cleaners come in a wide array of styles, function and design. In general, they all work off of your return pump with some requiring a booster pump to help them scrub and remove  difficult dirt and debris. Alternately, self-contained robotic models work off a battery pack and are equipped with their own brushes and capture bag that keeps grime out of your pools filtration system.

With pool cleaners, the axiom of “you get what you pay for” generally rings true. The most expensive types will be completely automatic, while the least expensive models may be nothing more than an underwater broom attached to a tube for manually sweeping the pool sides and bottom. Be sure to check out our automatic pool cleaner buyer's guide below which contains useful information to help you choose a unit best suited for your needs.

Best Pressure Pool Cleaner:

Pressure pool cleaners use the pressure generated by your pool pump, or a dedicated booster pump, to clean the bottom of your pool with a pressurized vacuum, while using jetted water to sweep the sides. They suck up debris from the bottom and deposit all the waste material into a bag, filtering the water as it goes back into the pool.

Some models work on your pool return line to generate enough suction pressure for the job. However, the more powerful types need an optional booster pump to work effectively, and that will add an additional cost above and beyond the purchase price of the cleaner itself.

The cleaners on this list were selected because they are the most effective at vacuuming out your pool, whether you need a booster pump or not. That being said, some pools do not need maximum power to keep them clean, so we also considered cleaners that run off of your regular pool pump and don't need a booster.

Kreepy Krauly Legend LL505GG Pressure Side Pool Cleaner

The Kreepy Krauly Legend Grey Top, White Bottom Pressure Side Pool Cleaner has 4-wheel stability, front wheel drive and an extra large debris bag to keep it working longer between empties. Read Full Review

See it at:
    Kreepy Krauly Legend LL505GG Pressure Side Pool Cleaner

    Zodiac F1 Polaris Vac-Sweep 360 Head and Hose Pressure Side Pool Cleaner

    The Zodiac F1 Polaris Vac-Sweep 360 Head and Hose Pressure Side Pool Cleaner uses no booster. It will clean virtually any pool in 3 hours or less, and will work effectively under a solar blanket. Read Full Review

    See it at:
      Zodiac F1 Polaris Vac-Sweep 360 Head and Hose Pressure Side Pool Cleaner

      Zodiac 6-120-00 Polaris Vac-Sweep 165 Pressure Side Pool Cleaner

      The Zodiac 6-120-00 Polaris Vac-Sweep 165 Pressure Side Pool Cleaner has a distintive shape to maximize cleaning effectiveness. It comes with an easy to detach filter bag and is the best bang for the buck unit listed here. Read Full Review

      See it at:
        Zodiac 6-120-00 Polaris Vac-Sweep 165 Pressure Side Pool Cleaner

        Zodiac 6-130-00T Polaris Turbo Turtle Pressure Side Pool Cleaner

        The Polaris 65 Turbo Turtle Above Ground Pressure Side Automatic Pool Cleaner will clean your pool in three hours or less, it needs no booster pump, and it will be delightful to watch as it works. Read Full Review

        See it at:
          Zodiac 6-130-00T Polaris Turbo Turtle Pressure Side Pool Cleaner

          Polaris 380 Pressure Side Automatic Pool Cleaner

          The Polaris 380 Pressure Side Automatic Pool Cleaner is the most powerful cleaner listed, it uses an optional booster pump and will clean sides, bottoms and even stairs. Read Full Review

          See it at:
            Polaris 380 Pressure Side Automatic Pool Cleaner

            Best Suction Pool Cleaner:

            Suction pool cleaners look like funky broom heads attached to a hose. Although they are automatic and will clean walls as well as pool bottoms, they do this in a random fashion so spots may be missed during the cleaning process. But they are some of the least expensive pool cleaners available. Each type is dedicated for either above ground pool cleaning or in-ground pool cleaning, so get the one that fits your needs.

            The models on this list were selected because they are the best cleaning units available, but versatility, price and durability was also taken into consideration.

            Zodiac W70472 Baracuda G2 Automatic Pool Cleaner

            The Zodiac W70472 Baracuda G2 Automatic Pool Cleaner is affordable, durable and will clean both your pool walls and the pool bottom. Read Full Review

            See it at:
              Zodiac W70472 Baracuda G2 Automatic Pool Cleaner

              Zodiac Baracuda W01698 Ranger Suction Side Automatic Above-Ground Pool Cleaner

              The Baracuda W01698 Ranger Suction Side Automatic Above-Ground Pool Cleaner is inexpensive, effective and has a unique Flowkeeper valve to automaticaly regulate the water flow for maximum performance in any above ground pool. Read Full Review

              See it at:
                Zodiac Baracuda W01698 Ranger Suction Side Automatic Above-Ground Pool Cleaner

                Pentair GW8000 Lil' Shark Pool Cleaner

                The Pentair Lil' Shark Pool Cleaner has brushes to provide a scrubbing action on pool walls and bottoms. It can be converted to hand vac by using a pole, and has 5 adjustable cleaning paths to get all of the dirt and grime. Read Full Review

                See it at:
                  Pentair GW8000 Lil' Shark Pool Cleaner

                  Pentair K70405 Kreepy Krauly Classic Inground Automatic Pool Suction-Side Cleaner

                  The Pentair K70405 Kreepy Krauly Classic Inground Automatic Pool Suction-Side Cleaner is the most expensive cleaner listed here, but it comes with a 2 year warranty, a durable flapper propulsion valve and will give you superior results. Read Full Review

                  See it at:
                    Pentair K70405 Kreepy Krauly Classic Inground Automatic Pool Suction-Side Cleaner

                    Kokido Derby Automatic Vac Above Ground Swimming Pool Vacuum Cleaner

                    The Kokido Derby Automatic Vac Above Ground Swimming Pool Vacuum Cleaner is the least expensive cleaner on this list and works best on steel walled above ground pools. Read Full Review

                    See it at:
                      Kokido Derby Automatic Vac Above Ground Swimming Pool Vacuum Cleaner

                      Best Robotic Pool Cleaner:

                      For many, pool cleaning is a serious hassle. But if you have a robotic pool cleaner, just set it in the water and let it do its thing. No muss, no fuss, and the best ones climb the walls and clean up to the water line.In all cases, the top rated ones will clean your pool and climb the walls, and after that, your pool cleaning should be down to a minimum of, perhaps, brushing the stairs. These units are expensive, so priority in selecting these were given to cleaning and ease of use although price was considered.

                      Dolphin 9999313-SWV Dolphin Advantage Plus RC Robotic Pool Cleaner with Swivel Cable

                      The Dolphin 9999313-SWV Dolphin Advantage Plus RC Robotic Pool Cleaner with Swivel Cable comes with a remote control for manual cleaning, features a 1-hour rapid cleaning cycle and the swivel cable keeps the cord out of the way. Read Full Review

                      See it at:
                        Dolphin 9999313-SWV Dolphin Advantage Plus RC Robotic Pool Cleaner with Swivel Cable

                        Pentair 360032 Kreepy Krauly Prowler 830 Robotic Inground Pool Cleaner

                        The Kreepy Krauly Prowler 830 Robotic Automatic Pool Cleaner features a swivel cord design to keep the cord from tangling, it has a remote control for manual cleaning and a built-in timer to clean when you are away. Read Full Review

                        See it at:
                          Pentair 360032 Kreepy Krauly Prowler 830 Robotic Inground Pool Cleaner

                          Hayward Shark VAC Pool Cleaner

                          The Hayward SharkVac Robotic Pool Cleaner gives you the most bang for the buck in a robotic. The top mounted filtration makes it easy to clean once it is done with your pool, it will climb walls and is the least expensive cleaner here. Read Full Review

                          See it at:
                            Hayward Shark VAC Pool Cleaner

                            Water Tech BLD03RC Blue Diamond RC Robotic Pool Cleaner

                            The Water Tech BLD03RC Blue Diamond RC Robotic Pool Cleaner is completely programmable, comes with a remote control for manual operation, and will climb walls for total pool cleaning. Read Full Review

                            See it at:
                              Water Tech BLD03RC Blue Diamond RC Robotic Pool Cleaner

                              Aqua Products Pool Rover S2-50

                              The Aqua Products Pool Rover S2-50 is the lowest priced robotic on the list, but it cleans with the best of them. It will climb inclined walls, has basic on/off and timer controls and the swivel cable is tangle free. Read Full Review

                              See it at:
                                Aqua Products Pool Rover S2-50
                                 

                                Automatic Pool Cleaner Buyers Guide

                                The first pool cleaner was actually designed as a cistern cleaner back in the late 1800's. A suction pump hose was attached to a crude type of hollow arm, and this was dragged over the bottom of the cistern tank to remove built-up sludge and other gunk. From there, it became a small step to adapt that technology into cleaning the bottom of swimming pools.

                                1939 saw the first adaption of the suction pump being attached to driving wheels on a pool cleaner to give them freedom of movement, while in1967 came the first electrically powered pool cleaner which didn't need to be attached to the filtration pump.

                                Today, there are three main types of automated pool cleaners available today, two of which depend on the water filtration system of your pool filter pump, and one of them which is totally robotic and wholly independent as it goes about its cleaning duties.

                                Automatic Pool Cleaner Types

                                Suction Cleaner
                                These are the least expensive pool cleaners and rely totally on the pool pump and filtration medium. They work simply by hooking up a hose from the pump to the unit, dropping it into the pool and letting it randomly crawl around on the bottom and up the sides of the pool. Eventually, it will make it to every part of the pool by way of its randomized movements.

                                A suction cleaner operates by using rotating brushes (much like a vacuum cleaner beater bar) that scrape and dislodge debris which then gets sucked into the pool filtration system. The design is upfront and basic, they’re easy to use, and obviously the least expensive, all qualities which make these units the most popular cleaners available.

                                Pressure Suction Cleaner
                                A pressure suction cleaner also employs the suction from the filter pump but also has its own built-in pump that increases the pressure within the unit. This increased suction pressure gets more of the scum and gunk off the pool bottom, and works the best on algae growth.

                                These units are a bit more complex, and naturally that means they’ll be a bit more expensive; however, they work better with lower rated pumps, making them a bit more flexible for any type of pool regardless of the filtration system being used.

                                Robotic Cleaner
                                These are fully programmable cleaners that use their own external power source. These are the only pool cleaner types that do not rely on the pool pump or the filtration system since they’re completely self contained.

                                These are the most expensive pool cleaners, and you'll need a dedicated electrical power source located outside of your pool. The cleaner is tethered by a waterproof electrical cord and they're equipped with their own filtration collection bag within. Most come with two different motors, one for the drive wheels/brushes and another for the suction pump.

                                If regular cleaning is done, the filter bag or canister can be emptied when the unit has finished. However, if the pool is very dirty (such as during the first cleaning of the spring) the process may have to be stopped a couple of times to empty the filter bag/canister.

                                Features

                                Bump Bars
                                These little bars/fenders extend slightly out and away from the main unit, telling the pool cleaner when to turn if it hits a wall or stairs. They can be activated or deactivated if you want just the bottom of the pool cleaned or you want your pool cleaner to go up the sides. The most basic automatic pool cleaners that don't have side cleaning capability rely on bump bars so they don't get stuck at a wall or in a corner.

                                2 Wheel Drive
                                Due to their smaller, compact nature, 2 wheel drive cleaners aren’t quite as efficient when it comes to cleaning a pool. These units are best suited for smaller pools and will provide a surprisingly effective amount of cleaning capability, provided dirt and debris are loose and not caked on.

                                4 Wheel Drive
                                These are the most effective and most efficient cleaners available. The 4 wheel drive system allows the use of larger and more effective brushes, the design has greater suction capability, and these particular units are better at climbing walls and stairs.

                                Better still are the tank tread variation attached over the wheels on premium models. This gives them extra grip on pool bottoms as well as when going up and down the sides of the pool.

                                Filter Bag/Canister
                                Robotic-style pool cleaners all have filter bags or a hard shell canister, but some have dual bags/canisters for extended cleaning chores. On more advanced units, when the first filterbag/canister fills up, the unit automatically transfers the vacuum stream to the empty one. When they both fill, the unit automatically shuts off and returns to where it started to be serviced.

                                Programmable Timer
                                Robotic pool cleaners have varying degrees of timer programmability. Basic programming allows you to program in the time you want the unit to clean, while more advanced programming allows users to punch in a daily schedule. Remote sensing capability will let you point a remote control at a specific area of the pool, and the cleaner will take care of the affected area and go back to its starting position.

                                What's Best for You

                                What's best for you depends on the type of pool you have, and to a lesser extent, on the power of your filtration pump.

                                Above Ground Pool
                                Let's make a distinction about the type of above ground pool here. The weekend fill-and-empty types don't need a pool cleaner, and they’re basically used for parties and kids so they’ll only be used on a temporary basis. They’re mostly inflatable or hard-shell plastic, and there is no connection for a filtration system of any kind.

                                The most common permanent type of above ground pool generally has a frame that holds up the liner. Because of this frame, side crawling suction cleaners do not work well, or they don't work at all. A basic suction cleaner which attaches to your pump hose is all you'd really need. However, most above ground pools come with pumps that aren’t very powerful, so it’s very important to get a suction pool cleaner rated for the horsepower of your pump. You can also upgrade to a higher power pump which eliminates any problems.

                                Of course, a pressure cleaner or a robotic cleaner would solve many of the deficiencies of a lower powered pump. The problem is these automatic pool cleaners may cost more than your pool, and although they would be excellent cleaners, the high cost may not justify their purchase.

                                Rectangular Below Ground Pools
                                Rectangular below ground pools are the easiest to clean and any type of cleaner would be suitable for use. If you clean regularly, a basic suction cleaner would be all you need, providing that your pump power is up to snuff. Pressure cleaners are a step up and meant for larger pools with the potential for algae growth, or if you simply prefer to have a heavier-duty cleaner. Robotic cleaners also work well in rectangular pools, but given their high price you might be better served to go with one or the other pump driven models.

                                Designer or Non-Rectangular Below Ground Pools
                                This is what a robotic pool cleaner is made for, and offers the best performance out of any of the other cleaner types. Since they’re not tethered to a hose, these units can move freely about the pool, easily negotiating curves and angles other pool cleaners might miss. They have less of a chance to get hung-up in a corner due to their innate directional sensing ability, and they can better navigate walls which don’t have square corners.

                                Can the other pool cleaners get the job done? Certainly! But afterwards, you may be out there with a manual pool cleaner to take care of the areas that they have missed. In most cases a robotic pool cleaner will clean almost every nook and cranny without you having to lift a finger.

                                Leave a Question or Comment