Best Eyebrow Pencil

Article Contents

Eyebrow pencils are like the icing on the cake when it comes to makeup. They add the finishing touch by filling in sparse spots, adding definition, and enhancing the color of your natural brows. Beyond adding color, many eyebrow pencils contain conditioning ingredients to promote healthy brows, and leave a polished, groomed appearance behind. If you don’t want to play a guessing game, there are plenty of brow pencils that come in universally flattering hues, so you can make the most of your brows - regardless of skin tone or brow color.

Best Eyebrow Pencil Overall:

Why we have that arched patch of hair above our eyelashes is still a mystery. Scientists believe it is to protect the eyes from moisture sweat, rain, etc. I believe it has an even greater purpose: to give our facial features a distinctive edge, and to provide our expressions with an originality they would not otherwise have. So often we neglect our eyebrows, concentrating on defining our eyes, lips, and cheeks. A well-defined, arched eyebrow does wonders for the face, and is just as important to highlight as those eyes, lips, and cheeks. Whether you need a slight filling in of the brow, or dramatic shape and definition, the Best Eyebrow Pencils below promise a gorgeous look.

Christian Dior Diorshow Brow Styler Pencil

The universal shade looks natural on everyone, and the ultra-fine tip helps enhance brows with precision. The creamy, waterproof formula lasts until you wash it off with soap and water. Read Full Review

See it at:
    Christian Dior Diorshow Brow Styler Pencil

    Kevyn Aucoin The Precision Brow Pencil - Brunette

    Kevyn Aucoin's ultra-slim eyebrow pencil is ideal for precision lining. The color is natural and can be blended for extra softening, using the blending wand at the other end of the pencil. Read Full Review

    See it at:
      Kevyn Aucoin The Precision Brow Pencil - Brunette

      MAC Eyebrow Pencil

      This self-sharpening and self-propelling pencil goes on smooth, is easy to blend, and lasts all day. Available in six shades, there's a natural-looking match for every hair color and skin tone. Read Full Review

      See it at:
        MAC Eyebrow Pencil

        T. LeClerc Eyebrow Pencil

        The powdery formula has major staying power, and naturally defines and accentuates the brows. The attached spooly brush helps blend color, but the pencil should be sharpened before each use to get a fine point. Read Full Review

        See it at:
          T. LeClerc Eyebrow Pencil

          Lancome 'Le Crayon Poudre' Brow Powder Pencil

          With a broad spectrum of shades and blendable, powdery color that lasts, this pencil yields a natural effect every time. The attached spooly brush helps achieve a groomed, even appearance every time. Read Full Review

          See it at:
            Lancome 'Le Crayon Poudre' Brow Powder Pencil

            Best Drugstore Eyebrow Pencil:

            Like most other cosmetics, you don’t always have to spend a bundle on eyebrow pencils to get the desired result. These cosmetics are a finishing touch that adds polish to any look, day or night — without breaking the bank. From traditional pencils to dual-purpose products with attached brushes or tinted brow gels, these drugstore eyebrow pencils can be used to fill in sparse spots or add overall definition. These picks in particular are definitely worth a look.

            Revlon Brow Fantasy Pencil

            This eyebrow pencil comes with a tinted gel that holds color and shape in place all day. The pencil is blend-able, and the gel can be used on its own for more casual occasions. Read Full Review

            See it at:
              Revlon Brow Fantasy Pencil

              Cover Girl Brow and Eye Makers Pencil

              Though better as an eyebrow pencil than eyeliner, this pencil offers neutral, water-resistant color that stays in place. For the most natural result, sharpen the pencil before each use. Read Full Review

              Cover Girl Brow and Eye Makers Pencil

              Maybelline Define-A-Brow Eyebrow Pencil

              With no sharpening necessary and natural, blend-able color, this is a great eyebrow pencil. The attached comb could be better, but the pencil's fine point allows for precise application. Read Full Review

              See it at:
                Maybelline Define-A-Brow Eyebrow Pencil

                Rimmel Professional Eyebrow Pencil

                This basic eyebrow pencil enhances brows without leaving a waxy or greasy residue. The color goes on smooth and blends easily. Read Full Review

                See it at:
                  Rimmel Professional Eyebrow Pencil

                  Almay Brow Defining Pencil

                  This self-sharpening pencil conditions eyebrows as it defines their shape and enhances color. The ultra-fine tip makes it great for filling in sparse spots. Read Full Review

                  See it at:
                    Almay Brow Defining Pencil

                    Best Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil:

                    The point of eyebrow pencil is to fill in sparse spots and add definition, but sometimes you need a product that can withstand sweating and swimming. That’s where a waterproof eyebrow pencil comes in, and these brow definers have the power to stay put until you wash them off with cleanser and water. Ideal for the gym, a day at the beach or any day for that matter, these eyebrow pencils allow your brows to look their best, regardless of what you’re doing!

                    Christian Dior Diorshow Brow Styler Pencil

                    This amazing brow pencil gives a natural result that lasts no matter where your day takes you. The one-shade-fits-all color makes selection a no-brainer, and the attached brush lets you groom your brows on the go. Read Full Review

                    Christian Dior Diorshow Brow Styler Pencil

                    Tarte Amazonian Clay Waterproof Brow Pencil

                    This versatile pencil's super-thin tip lets you fill in gaps or add definition to the entire brow. Because it's made with clay, it minimizes oil around the hair follicles so color lasts and lasts. Read Full Review

                    Tarte Amazonian Clay Waterproof Brow Pencil

                    Stila Cosmetics Stay All Day Waterproof Brow Color

                    This brow definer's felt tip works more like a marker than a pencil, making it easy to add color just where you want to. The formulation eliminates clumps and waxy buildup. Read Full Review

                    See it at:
                      Stila Cosmetics Stay All Day Waterproof Brow Color

                      Sephora Collection Retractable Brow Pencil - Waterproof

                      The most budget-friendly of the bunch, this retractable pencil always has a sharp point for precise application. The attached comb helps groom brows and blend color. Read Full Review

                      See it at:
                        Sephora Collection Retractable Brow Pencil - Waterproof

                        Smashbox Brow Tech To Go

                        With a waterproof pencil on one end and clear brow fixative gel on the other, this is a complete brow grooming kit in one tube. The pencil has an angled tip for precise application, and it goes on smooth without leaving any residue. Read Full Review

                        See it at:
                          Smashbox Brow Tech To Go

                          Best Combo Eyebrow Pencil:

                          A fantastic eyebrow pencil is great, but one that has an added bonus such as brow fixative gel or a pair of tweezers is even better. These combo products make it a cinch to get perfectly groomed brows even on the go, save room in your makeup bag, and ensure that you’re never rummaging through your cosmetic case for a brow brush and other brow accessories again.

                          Pixi Beauty Natural Brow Duo

                          The waterproof pencil has an angled tip that never needs to be sharpened, and the tinted fixative gel keeps brows (and color) in place. The universal shade flatters all skin tones and hair colors. Read Full Review

                          See it at:
                            Pixi Beauty Natural Brow Duo

                            Josie Maran Argan Magic Brows Brow Marker + Brow Powder Duo

                            This brow marker has an ultra-fine tip so you can draw on individual "hairs", and a brow powder that beautifully defines and accentuates the brows. It's also all-natural for those who stick to a "green" beauty routine. Read Full Review

                            See it at:
                              Josie Maran Argan Magic Brows Brow Marker + Brow Powder Duo

                              Revlon Brow Fantasy Pencil

                              A brow pencil and tinted fixative gel in one, this budget-friendly option saves money without sacrificing results. The gel can also be used alone for more casual occasions. Read Full Review

                              See it at:
                                Revlon Brow Fantasy Pencil

                                L'Oreal Brow Stylist Professional

                                With the brow pencil, tweezers, and a brow brush, this one product gives you major bang for your buck - and the ability to create perfectly groomed brows anytime, anywhere. Read Full Review

                                See it at:
                                  L'Oreal Brow Stylist Professional

                                  Smashbox Brow Tech To Go

                                  With a retractable, angled, waterproof brow pencil plus clear brow fixative gel, this one product makes it easy to create beautiful brows. The pencil goes on smooth without leaving waxy residue. Read Full Review

                                  See it at:
                                    Smashbox Brow Tech To Go

                                    Best Natural Eyebrow Pencil:

                                    An eyebrow pencil is a key component in every makeup bag, but you don’t have to settle for one riddled with artificial and synthetic ingredients. With more and more natural and organic cosmetics hitting the market, it’s now possible to get a great eyebrow pencil that’s mindful of your skin and the environment. These natural eyebrow pencils get the job done, and help put your conscience at ease — and you probably wouldn’t know they were natural if we didn’t tell you!

                                    Tarte Amazonian Clay Waterproof Brow Pencil

                                    With a super-thin tip and the ability to withstand a hard workout or even a dip in the pool, this is our top natural brow pencil pick. It goes on smooth, blends well, and the retractable tip means a perfect point every time you apply. Read Full Review

                                    Tarte Amazonian Clay Waterproof Brow Pencil

                                    Josie Maran Argan Magic Brows Brow Marker + Brow Powder Duo

                                    This long-lasting brow marker has a super-fine tip for optimal precision, and the attached brow powder defines the brows' shape and color while looking extremely natural. Read Full Review

                                    See it at:
                                      Josie Maran Argan Magic Brows Brow Marker + Brow Powder Duo

                                      Lavera Eyebrow Pencil All Brows

                                      This natural eyebrow pencil has no bells and whistles, but the universal shade makes it great for all skin tones and hair colors. It contains moisturizing shea butter and jojoba oil to condition brows as you wear it. Read Full Review

                                      See it at:
                                        Lavera Eyebrow Pencil All Brows

                                        Origins Fill In The Blanks Eyebrow Enhancer

                                        With a thin tip for precise application, this eyebrow pencil is great because of its retractable, always-sharp tip. The attached spooly brush is perfect for blending color and grooming unruly brows. Read Full Review

                                        Origins Fill In The Blanks Eyebrow Enhancer

                                        Shobha Brow Pencil

                                        With buildable water-resistant color, you can layer on this pencil to fill in sparse spots or add overall definition. The built-in sharpener means you never have to rummage through your makeup bag again. Read Full Review

                                        See it at:
                                          Shobha Brow Pencil

                                          Best Conditioning Eyebrow Pencil:

                                          Some of these conditioning eyebrow pencils contain color and some do not, but they are all formulated with ingredients that soften, nourish, and condition the eyebrows. Most of these products double as lightweight brow fixatives as well, so you also get a little help for keeping errant hairs in place. But perhaps the best thing about these conditioning eyebrow pencils is that you don’t have to be too precise with application, making them a breeze to use.

                                          Anastasia Brow Fix

                                          This is the ultimate brow fixative with hair-conditioning benefits. You get soft, healthy brows, and a multitude of uses. From lips to eyelids and beyond, it's infused with aloe and vitamin E to soothe and protect the skin. Read Full Review

                                          See it at:
                                            Anastasia Brow Fix

                                            MAC Cosmetics MAC Brow Finisher

                                            The thin, pointed tip of this waxy pencil helps seal in color and add the finishing touch to the brows. It goes on smooth, and doesn't leave a stiff or sticky feel. Read Full Review

                                            See it at:
                                              MAC Cosmetics MAC Brow Finisher

                                              Lavera Eyebrow Pencil All Brows

                                              Perfect for sensitive skin, this one-shade-fits-all brow pencil is 100% natural and contains organic shea butter and jojoba oil to condition each individual hair. Read Full Review

                                              See it at:
                                                Lavera Eyebrow Pencil All Brows

                                                It Cosmetics Brow Power Universal Brow Pencil

                                                Available in one univeral shade (with an attached brush for blending and grooming), this gel-based brow pencil adds shape and definition while promoting healthy hair follicles with biotin, green tea, and other botanical ingredients. Read Full Review

                                                See it at:
                                                  It Cosmetics Brow Power Universal Brow Pencil

                                                  Too Faced Brow-nie Brow Pencil

                                                  This powder-based brow pencil fills in, shapes, defines, and holds color and hairs in place while nourishing the brows with cocoa bean. It goes on smooth without feeling waxy, and the attached brush helps you groom brows to perfection. Read Full Review

                                                  Too Faced Brow-nie Brow Pencil

                                                  Best Eyebrow Highlighter Pencil:

                                                  If you want to look completely pulled together in a snap, then stash one of these travel friendly brow pencils into your beauty bag. You may not be used to using one of these, but if you spend so much time on your hair and eye makeup why wouldn't you want to frame your artwork with the perfect brow. These highlighters will instantly give your face a fresh and lifted look while directing the on-looker to go straight to your gorgeous peepers. All of these incredible products will help brows look sculpted, lifted and glide on like butter. You will not need to worry about irritation "dragging" or cake-face. All of these have been selected due to their ease of use and quality ingredients.

                                                  Jane Iredale Doubly Dazzling Highlighter Pencils

                                                  If you want a product that can make you look pulled together in a snap, then this pencil is that. It is rich and creamy and glides on effortlessly. It comes in a white and pink duo or a tan and auburn shade. You will notice brighter eyes and tidy brows, so this on the go for touch ups. Read Full Review

                                                  Jane Iredale Doubly Dazzling Highlighter Pencils

                                                  Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Duality

                                                  If you want versatility, perfection and a great product for your buck then you must try this one from Anastaia Beverly Hills. It really is perfect tool to take your favorite eye looks to the next level. One side of the pencil is matte and the other side is shimmery for either bold or subtle styles. Read Full Review

                                                  Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Duality

                                                  NYX Eyebrow Push-Up Bra

                                                  NYX is the perfect pencil your makeup bag has been missing. One side of the pencil will highlight, lift and define the brows. The pencil on the other end is designed to help you fill in color giving brows a full and modern look. Read Full Review

                                                  See it at:
                                                    NYX Eyebrow Push-Up Bra

                                                    Chella Ivory Lace Highlighter Pencil

                                                    If you are looking for a highlighter pencil for a darker skin tone, then this product is a great option. It comes in a universal nude tone but is also available in tan, auburn and brown shades. This product really is perfect for any skin tone, and can actually double as a lip highlighter too. Read Full Review

                                                    See it at:
                                                      Chella Ivory Lace Highlighter Pencil

                                                      Clinique Instant Lift For Brows

                                                      All pencils do not require a sharpener, such as this one from Clinique. Instant Lift for brows comes in 3 dual color combinations to take your eye looks from a natural daytime to shimmery night time look in one. Clinique is always safe, gentle and hypoallergenic. Read Full Review

                                                      See it at:
                                                        Clinique Instant Lift For Brows
                                                        Leave a Question or Comment