Best Mouse Trap

Article Contents

Although there are many different species of mice, the ones primarily targeted by mouse traps, are the common house mouse and both the deer mouse and white footed mouse. House mice are most often found in city dwellings, while the deer and white footed are generally found in suburban areas. If given the opportunity, all of these species of mice will invade a home and can potentially become a serious problem.

While mouse traps may be effective over the short run, if a mouse population has become established in your house or home, the chances are that trapping alone may not cure the problem. But they’re a start, and if kept baited and active at all times, they’ll take care of the overly curious mouse looking for a new place to live before it can settle in.

Modern mouse traps are designed to be effective and user friendly. There are several types which work effectively, including live traps, automatic types, and even newer electronic options. You can get a better idea of these different trap types and which might be best suited for your situation by reading through our mouse trap buyer’s guide provided below.

Best Mouse Trap Overall:

Mouse infestation can occur in any residence at any time. Once established in your home or business, they will become a real nuisance, and can become a serious health problem as well. The age old way to deal with a mouse problem is to trap them in a lethal trap and dispose of them. Although this may seem cruel, a humanely live trapped mouse has little to no chance at survival, once it is released into surroundings that it is unfamiliar with.

However, we are not here to debate the ethics of trapping mice, we are here to give you the best option available on a trap that is effective and easy to use. The best one will be easy to set, be 100 percent effective when a mouse takes the bait yet be cost effective if you choose to dispose of the trap and the mouse together.

JT Eaton 409BULK Jawz Plastic Mouse Trap

The JT Eaton 409BULK Jawz Plastic Mouse Trap is a better mouse trap, that is 100 percent effective when a mouse takes the bait. Simple to set, just pull back the top lever until the trap locks into place. So simple, you can even set it with your foot. They can be purchased in singles or bulk for more cost effectiveness. Read Full Review

See it at:
    JT Eaton 409BULK Jawz Plastic Mouse Trap

    Victor Metal Pedal Mouse Trap

    The Victor Metal Pedal Mouse Trap is based on the original mouse trap design. It is effective and very inexpensive. This is the most bang for the buck trap available. They are so inexpensive, you can set it, trap a mouse, dispose of the trap and all, and set a new one. Simple and easy. Read Full Review

    See it at:
      Victor Metal Pedal Mouse Trap

      The Better Mousetrap

      The Better Mousetrap is a truly more modern and better design than the standard snap trap. Bait the bait cup, pull back the lever until the trigger platform locks into place and place the trap on a known mouse run. Easy to use and 100 percent effective when a mouse triggers the trap. Read Full Review

      See it at:
        The Better Mousetrap

        Rodent Terminator

        The Rodent Terminator is a state of the art electronic mouse trap that runs on batteries and will humanely kill any mouse that goes into it. Simply bait, turn it on and place it on a known mouse run. It has an optional wireless transmitter that lets you know when a mouse is inside. Although not inexpensive, this is the the best electronic mouse trap out there. Read Full Review

        See it at:
          Rodent Terminator

          Victor Pest Glue Board

          The Victor Pest Glue Board will effectively trap mice in situations where other traps won't work. Put bait in the center and place them along known mouse runs. They are so inexpensive that once caught, the mouse and trap can be disposed of all at once. Read Full Review

          See it at:
            Victor Pest Glue Board

            Best Humane Mouse Trap:

            Mice infestation can happen to anyone, and although there are many options to rid a household of mice incursions, the best feel good way is through humane trapping. Simply put, a humane trap catches a mouse that you then release, unharmed, at a place of your choosing. The mouse lives and goes free and you retain peace of mind that you did the right thing. It's as simple as that.

            This list will comprise the best humane mouse traps available. Chosen because they are effective, easy to bait and set. The top mouse catcher on this list comes with recommendations from respected humane and animal rights agencies, and you can't get better than that.

            Seabright Laboratories Smart Mouse Trap

            The Seabright Laboratories Smart Mouse Trap is endorsed by Animal Rights organizations world wide, it is easy to set, easy to bait and easy to release a captured mouse. No muss, no fuss and no harm to the mouse. Its just about the perfect humane trap available. Read Full Review

            See it at:
              Seabright Laboratories Smart Mouse Trap

              J.T. Eaton 420 Series Repeater Multiple Catch Mouse Trap w/Solid Lid

              The J.T. Eaton 420 Series Repeater Multiple Catch Mouse Trap w/Solid Lid is the best bang for the buck bargain available. This trap is terrific for large mice infestations because it will hold up to 30 mice before it needs to be emptied. Read Full Review

              See it at:
                J.T. Eaton 420 Series Repeater Multiple Catch Mouse Trap w/Solid Lid

                Havahart X-Small 2-Door Trap

                The Havahart X-Small 2-Door Trap has been the go-to trap for professionals and homeowners alike. Proven humane performance, quality built out of steel, it is easy to bait, set and open the door when it is time for release. No trap on this list can beat the reputation of a Havahart trap. Read Full Review

                Havahart X-Small 2-Door Trap

                Kness Tip-Trap Live Capture Mouse Trap

                The Kness Tip-Trap Live Capture Mouse Trap is the easiest humane mouse trap to use on this list. Simply bait at the far end and let the mouse's own weight trip the trap. The durable plastic design can be rinsed and reused, and the door opens easily for release at a place of your choosing. Read Full Review

                See it at:
                  Kness Tip-Trap Live Capture Mouse Trap

                  Ketch-All Multiple Catch Mousetrap w/ Clear Lid

                  The Ketch-All Multiple Catch Mousetrap w/ Clear Lid catches 6 mice and lets you see inside of the trap by way of its clear top. Wind it up, place the trap on a known mouse run and the mice will get flicked inside when they step on the platform. Use bait or not, with an easy open rear door for release. Read Full Review

                  See it at:
                    Ketch-All Multiple Catch Mousetrap w/ Clear Lid

                    Best Mouse Bait:

                    Mouse bait is the substance used to attract a mouse to a trap. It doesn't matter what kind of trap it is, the sole intention of a mouse bait is to be so enticing that a mouse will willingly enter a trap.

                    There are three distinct types of mouse bait. A food source that a mouse loves to eat, synthetic types that a mouse would be interested in for nesting or comfort, and commercially made mouse attractant formulas, which are jells, pastes or putties that a mouse cannot resist. All of these types will be effective at luring a mouse into a trap, but the best one will include properties, like ease of use and effectiveness for a specific requirement, that will trump anything else on the list.

                    Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter

                    If you only use one mouse bait, use Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter. It is sticky, smells wonderful, adheres to anything and mice will go for peanut butter above all else. It is inexpensive and a little goes a long way. For any type of trap, peanut butter is the best. Read Full Review

                    See it at:
                      Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter

                      Johnson & Johnson Dental Floss

                      Mice love to be comfortable, and unless they are actively looking for food, they are building nests. Johnson & Johnson Dental Floss, un-waxed, placed in traps, meet the need of a mouse looking for nesting materials. Dental floss is one of the most overlooked yet effective means to entice a mouse to trigger a trap. Read Full Review

                      See it at:
                        Johnson & Johnson Dental Floss

                        Lipahtech Rat & Mouse Attractant

                        Lipahtech Rat & Mouse Attractant is the next best thing to peanut butter. It is easy to use, can be molded into any shape needed, it isn't messy and is effective in both snap traps or walk-in humane traps. Read Full Review

                        Lipahtech Rat & Mouse Attractant

                        Tomcat Mouse Attractant Gel

                        Tomcat Mouse Attractant Gel will work effectively in either walk-in traps or snap traps. The gel formula is non-toxic and non-allergenic, yet it washes up easily due to its water soluble composition. Just a couple of drops will lure any mouse into or onto the trap of your choice. Read Full Review

                        See it at:
                          Tomcat Mouse Attractant Gel

                          Provoke Professional Mouse Attractant

                          Provoke Professional Mouse Attractant is made to replace peanut butter for people who are allergic to nuts, or where peanut butter has been banned for use in traps. It's water soluble, won't stain material and is specially formulated to attract mice. Read Full Review

                          See it at:
                            Provoke Professional Mouse Attractant
                             

                            Mouse Trap Buyer's Guide

                            Without a doubt, a mice infestation is a nuisance. Although capable of carrying disease via parasites, they’re mostly just annoying to have around, and if they get into a food supply, they can soil and ruin it. Once established, mice breed quickly, so it’s best to eliminate these pests as fast as possible, or they can (and will) overwhelm a household or business.

                            Invented in the 1890’s, the original snap-trap is a spring-loaded wire arm mounted to a piece of wood, snaps shut on the neck of a feeding mouse, killing it instantly. The trap can then be reloaded with bait, the arm reset, and the trap can be used again and again.

                            In the decades since, people have been trying to re-engineer and build a better mouse trap. To that end, there are a host of designs available from the classic manual trap to high tech electronic options. You'll have to figure out what type works best for your situation, but if in doubt, simply start off with the familiar and easy to use snap trap.

                            Mouse Trap Types

                            Manual/Snap
                            All manual traps begin with the ubiquitous snap trap. The differences between these snap-trap types are nearly endless, with some having baited platforms that snap together, some that snap downwards and some that snap upwards, some are made to be used in a horizontal position and some are used in a vertical orientation.

                            Some of these are built to be disposable, so that you throw both the mouse and the trap away. Others have an easy-release mechanism so you can quickly dispose of the mouse and reset the trap. There are many variations of this type of trap, but they all use a spring loaded trigger system so that when the mouse takes the bait, the trap springs shut.

                            All snap traps have a spring loaded arm or a platform, propelled by a spring. They will feature some sort of bait cup or a bait station which triggers the spring when it’s disturbed as the mouse feeds. You’ll always need to physically set the trap by pulling back on the spring mechanism after the bait has been placed on the bait station. They must be placed around known areas of mice infestation and require regular checks, often several times per day.

                            Mice rarely become trap wary, which is why one trap placed in the same place will often continue to catch mice. But it is always a good idea to change the location of the trap when a few mice have been caught, just in case.

                            Live Traps
                            Live traps also come in many variations as well. Because mice are so small, these are essentially specialty traps that can only be used for mice. All of these types lure a mouse into a trap using bait or scented food drops, and when the mouse takes the bait, a door closes behind them.

                            These traps have many shapes and designs, but they all are essentially a small rectangular container where the bait is placed at the far end. A mouse enters one side, which is on the ground, and when it goes to get the bait, it passes over a fulcrum. The balance then shifts to the other side, rocking the original end off the ground and closing a trap door behind it.

                            Once the mouse is caught, you can release it alive and unharmed into an area away from your home or business, or you can humanely dispose of it. You may have to rinse out the trap before reusing it but this trap will continue to work over and over again.

                            Using a live trap means dealing with a live mouse once it is caught. However, if you are against killing mice for any reason, these are the only traps to use that will virtually guarantee that a mouse is captured unhurt and unharmed.

                            Electronic Traps
                            The newest type of mouse traps, electronic types are made to use food or pheromone drops as bait. These traps are boxy or can-shaped with an open end and a closed end. The mouse travels inside, goes to where the bait has been placed and once at the bait station, an electronic current is passed into the mouse, killing it.

                            Electronic traps come as either plug-in models or battery operated types. These traps must be checked regularly but some models feature an exterior light-up bulb when the trap has terminated a mouse. This feature makes them easy to check from a distance, and once a mouse has been caught, it can be quickly disposed of by dumping it out the open end.

                            Automatic Traps
                            These traps are best used for larger infestations because they can hold a multitude of mice before they need to be emptied, making them a staple in commercial settings where mice can be a problem. Large and bulky, these traps work best when placed on mouse runs where mice congregate. Live bait is used and pheromone drops will also work well to lure the mouse inside. Once captured, the mice can be released or disposed of humanely.

                            Automatic traps typically feature a spring-loaded platform which flings mice inside of the trap when it is disturbed. The scent of food and the scurrying mice inside attract other mice so that they keep stepping on the platform and continue to get trapped.

                            Since these are repeating traps, the spring is wound up so it can catch mouse after mouse without being checked or emptied. These traps re-set themselves and will catch one to two dozen mice before they need to be wound up again.

                            Glue Traps
                            These traps are generally square shaped and coated with a gluey substance. They can either be baited by placing the bait directly in the center of the trap or available pre-baited with a pheromone scent added into the glue. Sticky traps are made to be disposable, and in most cases, they will only catch one mouse at a time.

                            Once caught, the mouse will still be alive, and they should be disposed of in a humane manner. However, many people simply throw the trap (and the mouse) away; the mouse goes on to perish from exposure, dehydration, or starvation.

                            Wildlife organizations, such as PETA and the RSPCA have condemned the use of these glue traps and several business organizations throughout the country, including the Charles Schwab Corporation, have banned these traps in their facilities.

                            Leave a Question or Comment