Best Pacifier

Article Contents

Choosing the best pacifier for your infant will probably involve some trial and error. Though they may not be able to express their opinions, babies will let you know when a pacifier works well for them (and when it doesn't). Most parents find that pacifiers are invaluable in the first few months of life. In addition to soothing infants, some experts believe that pacifier use can also reduce the risk of SIDS. Whether you need a pacifier for a newborn, a breastfeeding infant, or an older baby, the products on these lists are all top-rated by parents and designed for babies at various stages of development. 

Best Pacifier Overall:

Some parents call it a binky while other refer to it as a "paci". You may even have your own special name for this essential baby accessory, but a pacifier can be a real lifesaver when it comes to soothing a fussy infant. Trying to find the best pacifier appropriate for your child will likely involve some trial and error until you find one that works for your baby. Fortunately, we've picked out the overall best baby pacifiers, each of which are an excellent option for your baby. All of the following pacifiers feature orthodontic-friendly designs so they won't disrupt the alignment of your baby's teeth, are available in a range of cute colors and stimullating designs, and they're all manufactured without potentially harmful synthetic compounds like BPA, PVC, or phthalates.

Playtex OrthoPro Silicone Pacifier

This pacifier features a dentally correct design which won't disrupt the alignment of your baby's teeth. Available in either silicone or latex, this pacificer also comes with it's AirComfort Shield so your baby will enjoy consistent air flow for easier sucking. Read Full Review

See it at:
    Playtex OrthoPro Silicone Pacifier

    NUK Advanced Orthodontic 100% Silicone Pacifier

    Thanks to the asymmetrical shape of this pacifier, it is able to fit more naturally to the contours of your baby's palate. The scoop nipple cavity allows for maximum tongue movement, increasing the soothing action this pacifier already provides. Read Full Review

    See it at:
      NUK Advanced Orthodontic 100% Silicone Pacifier

      MAM Air Silicone Pacifier

      Available in 4 stages, the MAM pacifiers offers soothing comfort from newborns to babies 16 months and up. The pacifers curved shield and large air holes provide comfortable use while preventing irritated skin. These pacifiers also come in a huge array of colors and designs, too. Read Full Review

      See it at:
        MAM Air Silicone Pacifier

        Dr. Brown's PreVent Design Pacifier

        This pacifier was designed by a pediatric dentist and features a PreVent design that lowers the pressure inside your baby's mouth while sucking on the pacifier. It also features a patented suction-free air channel which reduces the suction while raising babies comfort level. Read Full Review

        See it at:
          Dr. Brown's PreVent Design Pacifier

          RazBaby Keep-it-Clean Pacifier

          The built-in closing shield automatically closes when this pacifier is dropped so you don't have to worry about germs. The nipple is made of soft silicone and is orthodontic, which means this pacifier won't stop baby's teeth from developing correctly. Read Full Review

          See it at:
            RazBaby Keep-it-Clean Pacifier

            Best Pacifier for Breastfed Babies:

            There’s no doubt a pacifier can be a wonderfully soothing tool for an unhappy baby, as it mimics the sucking motion baby’s find so comforting. However, It’s usually recommended to wait until breastfeeding is established before trying to present baby with a pacifier as they can disrupt the development of a baby’s desire to latch with their mother for feeding. However, we’ve identified pacifiers that breastfed babies will be able to take which won’t disrupt the natural nursing bond they develop with their mother. We chose these best pacifiers for newborns because they’re designed with nipples that closely mimic moms to prevent nipple confusion, their orthodontic designs which won’t disrupt the alignment of baby’s developing teeth, and they have specialized features like airflow enhancers and specialized materials which reduce potential irritation of baby’s sensitive skin.

            Nuby Natural Flex Pacifiers

            The nipple on this pacifier flexes and stretches the way that mom's breast does, which prevents nipple confusion for baby. It also features patented nubs to massage baby's gums which enhances the pacifiers already soothing effects. Read Full Review

            Nuby Natural Flex Pacifiers

            The First Years Gumdrop Pacifier

            This is the pacifier that most hospitals choose to give newborn babies thanks in part to the durable one-piece design which is very easy to clean. The nipple features a natural shape just like mom's and it’s contoured so it won't interfere with the development of baby's teeth. Read Full Review

            See it at:
              The First Years Gumdrop Pacifier

              NUK Advanced Orthodontic 100% Silicone Pacifier

              The orthodontic design of this pacifier conforms to the shape of baby's mouth, just like mom's breast does. This pacifier comes with the Nuk Air System which allows the nipple to adjust on its own so that it can create a proper fit to the shape of your baby's mouth. Read Full Review

              See it at:
                NUK Advanced Orthodontic 100% Silicone Pacifier

                Philips Avent BPA Free Contemporary Freeflow Pacifier

                The nipple of this pacifier is symmetrical, collapsible and orthodontic, meaning it conforms to the shape of baby's mouth, just like mom's breast. This pacifier is made of soft, BPA-free silicone and the curved shield with extra vents prevents babies skin from getting irritated. Read Full Review

                See it at:
                  Philips Avent BPA Free Contemporary Freeflow Pacifier

                  Natursutten BPA Free Natural Rubber Pacifier

                  Made from rubber that comes from the Hevea brasilensis tree, this is the only pacifier on the market that is made from 100 percent natural materials. The orthodontic nipple conforms to the shape of baby's mouth and helps prevent the misalignment of developing teeth. Read Full Review

                  See it at:
                    Natursutten BPA Free Natural Rubber Pacifier

                    Best Pacifier for Newborns:

                    Just like diapers and feeding formulas, there are also pacifiers specifically designed for a newborn. What sets the newborn pacifier apart is they’re smaller and will have a specialized shape that’s more comfortable for a newborn’s mouth to suckle on. While there are multiple pacifiers on the market that are designed for newborns, we’ve chosen the following best options because they feature orthodontic nipples best suited for a newborns mouth. They also closely mimic the shape of mom’s nipple to avoid confusion, and they have been designed with unique shapes with a groove below the nose which provides maximum comfort for baby as they suckle away.

                    MAM Start Pacifier

                    The MAM start is specifically designed to be the first pacifier a baby uses, making it a top pick on our Best Pacifiers for Newborns list. As a bonus, this binky comes with its own carry case that can also be used for sterilization in the microwave. Read Full Review

                    See it at:
                      MAM Start Pacifier

                      NUK Advanced Orthodontic 100% Silicone Pacifier

                      The asymmetrical shape of this pacifier naturally conforms to baby's mouth which creates less pressure and allows for a more natural suckling motion. The heart-shape design allows this pacifier to fit comfortably under baby's nose. Read Full Review

                      See it at:
                        NUK Advanced Orthodontic 100% Silicone Pacifier

                        The First Years Gumdrop Pacifier

                        The contoured shape of this pacifier provides plenty of space for baby's nose, making it comfortable to use. The lightweight design also makes it easier for your newborn to hold onto. Read Full Review

                        See it at:
                          The First Years Gumdrop Pacifier

                          Munchkin Latch Lightweight Pacifier

                          The natural-shaped nipple on this pacifier allows a newborn to create a natural latch and makes it easy to transition between breast and pacifier. The one-piece silicone design makes this pacifier super lightweight and easy for your newborn to use. Read Full Review

                          See it at:
                            Munchkin Latch Lightweight Pacifier

                            Philips Avent BPA Free Contemporary Freeflow Pacifier

                            This pacifier an ideal choice for a newborn because six air holes keeps their sensitive skin dry while the butterfly shape allows for the perfect fit between your baby's nose and the pacifier. The soft but durable orthodontic nipple is designed to create a natural suckling motion. Read Full Review

                            See it at:
                              Philips Avent BPA Free Contemporary Freeflow Pacifier
                              Leave a Question or Comment