Best Roasting Pan
Whether you're cooking up a turkey for a holiday meal or a roast for a family dinner, a specialized roasting pan will help you get the job done. These pans are deeper than most other baking pans and some of them can be moved from the oven to the stovetop in case you're making gravy. Some pans are lidless, giving plenty of vertical space, while others come with high domed lids that trap the juices inside and prevent meats from drying out.
Baking pans come in a number of different materials. Steel pans are sturdy, inexpensive, and lightweight, though they may require some extra care because most have non-stick coatings that can be damaged by metal utensils. Ceramic, stoneware, and porcelain pans are heavy duty, incredibly strong, and usually safe to use with metal utensils, but some of them can be a hassle to clean. Foil pans are designed for one use only and, while they are cheap, aren't the most sturdy pans out there, which means you'll have to be extra careful taking your meal out of the oven.
Best Roasting Pan Overall:
If you're thinking about roasting a chicken or ham, a good roasting pan is a must. These pans feature a deep baking dish with a metal rack that fits inside so that you can cook a roast and catch the drippings in the same pan. When looking for the best roasting pans, we only considered those that came with both these essential pieces. We also looked for pans that were sturdy enough to hold up to frequent use and easy to clean up when you're done roasting.
One of the best things about the Rachael Ray Enamel on Steel Roaster with Rack is that it can be used in the oven and on the stovetop, making it easy to cook a turkey and make gravy with one dish. This pan is made from enamel coated steel that is durable and easy to clean and it features wide handles that won't slip when you take it out of the oven. Read Full Review
A versatile roasting pan that can be used to cook a chicken, turkey, or large roast, the Cuisinart 16 inch Roasting Pan with Rack is one of our Best Picks. This pan is made of solid stainless steel that cooks evenly and cleans up easily. The roasting pan also has convenient handles that make it easy to carry it into or out of the oven. Read Full Review
Made of tri-ply aluminum, the Calphalon Contemporary Stainless Roasting Pan with Rack heats up and cools down faster than pans made of other materials. This pan allows for maximum airflow while providing a deep enough pan to catch any drippings and juices that drip off the roast while it's cooking. It's also easy to clean and is dishwasher safe. Read Full Review
If you're looking for a roasting pan that's as easy to clean as it is to cook in, the Chicago Metallic Commercial II Non-Stick Roast & Broil Pan with Rack may be the pan for you. Made from reinforced aluminized steel, this non-stick pan is strong, sturdy, and big enough to fit even a large roast. Read Full Review
The All-Clad Roasters Stainless Collection Multi Tier Roaster is the perfect roasting pan when you have a lot of food to cook. It can accommodate a turkey and veggies, or family's worth of ribs or steaks by making use of more than one roasting rack. When it's time to put the roasting pan away, the pieces come apart easily and all of them are safe to put in the dishwasher. Read Full Review
Best High Covered Roasting Pan:
If you're cooking a turkey or a roast, a high covered roasting pan is an ideal piece of cookware that will help keep meat juicy as it cooks. In picking out the best high covered roasting pans, we chose strong steel pans that heat up evenly and are spacious enough to fit a large cut of meat. We also looked for pans that were easy to clean. Though many of these pans are safe to put in the dishwasher, most with last longer if you wash them by hand.
An extra-large, incredibly durable pan, the Granite Ware Covered Rectangle Roaster is a great buy. This dish is made from porcelain-coated steel that is both strong and, thanks to the porcelain, naturally non-stick. It's also scratch-proof so it's safe to use metal utensils when it's time to serve. Read Full Review
Made from a special stainless steel that's safe to use in the oven or on the stovetop, the WMF Stainless Steel Deep Oval Roasting Pan is one of the most popular pans on the market. It's sturdy, attractive, and at 16 inches long, 11 inches wide and 7 inches deep, it's roomy enough for a large roast. Read Full Review
One of the best things about the Fox Run Stainless Steel Oval Roaster With Rack And High Domed Lid is that it comes at a price that won't break the bank. This pan is a little thinner than many competitors, though it's still plenty strong to carry the weight of a medium-sized turkey. Read Full Review
Large enough to roast a 25 pound turkey, the T-Fal High Domed Covered Roaster is one of the most popular high covered roasting pans. One of the best parts of this pan is the incredible non-stick coating that's on both the inside and outside, making it easy to clean up after a big holiday meal. The pan also has strong steel handles and comes with a non-stick roasting rack. Read Full Review
The Vinaroz Stainless Steel Oval Roaster with Rack and High Lid is an extra-large high covered roasting pan that can fit a large turkey or roast. It's dishwasher safe, scratch resistant, and able to hold up to 9 quarts. Read Full Review
Best Disposable Roasting Pan:
For those who only need a roasting pan once a year for a holiday meal, a disposable roasting pan may be the way to go. These pans are made from heavy-duty foil that you can recycle once the turkey has been served. They are also quite inexpensive, especially compared with steel, porcelain, or stoneware roasting pans. Though many grocery stores and discount supply stores offer their own line of disposable bakeware, many of these are simply too flimsy to hold up to the weight of a large roast. We recommend these roasters because they are relatively sturdy and inexpensive. Since they are made out of foil, none of these pans is nearly as strong as a real roasting pan, so extra care should be taken when you're moving the pan into or out of the oven.
With a convenient roasting rack that lifts easily out of the pan, the Handifoil Lift Rack Handle Pan is a step above the competition. This pan is sturdy and large enough for a medium-sized turkey. It's also quite inexpensive and easy to recycle when you're done with it. Read Full Review
For extra large turkeys and roasts, the Handifoil KING Roaster is a great choice. This disposable roasting pan can easily fit a 25-pound bird and comes with sturdy handles that make it easy to move a heavy pan into or out of the oven. Handifoil also offers these large pans in oval and rectangular shapes. Read Full Review
The 13-by-11 inch Bake-N-Take Aluminum Roaster with Lid is a sturdy pan that is big enough to roast a medium turkey in. It's made of an extra-strong aluminum foil and comes with a clear plastic lid that makes it easy to store the leftovers when you're done. Read Full Review
The Hefty EZ Foil Oval Roaster is one of our Best Picks when it comes to disposable roasting pans because it's strong, big enough for a medium-sized turkey, and made by one of the leading names in disposable bakeware. With a plastic lid that fits snuggly on top, this pan can also double as a leftover container at the end of the meal. Read Full Review