We may earn a commission if you make a purchase through one of our links. Learn more

Cosmetics

Best Eyebrow Pencil

Eyebrow pencils are like the icing on the cake when it comes to makeup. They add the finishing touch by filling in sparse spots, adding definition, and enhancing the color of your natural brows. Beyond adding color, many eyebrow pencils contain conditioning ingredients to promote healthy brows, and leave a polished, groomed appearance behind. If you don’t want to play a guessing game, there are plenty of brow pencils that come in universally flattering hues, so you can make the most of your brows - regardless of skin tone or brow color.

Jane Iredale Doubly Dazzling Highlighter Pencils

Jane Iredale Doubly Dazzling Highlighter Pencils

Jane Iredale gives a touch of luxury to all of her incredible mineral-based products. This pencil is perfect pencil for those of you who hate the feeling of dragging a hard tip across your soft delicate skin. Your eyes are the most sensitive and delicate are of the face, so you will love the butter-like consistency of this pencil. Not only is it safe on the skin but the main ingredients are mineral-based and will never irritate. This product is ideal for skin of all ages. It perks up eyes and makes you look naturally pulled together.

Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Duality

Anastasia Beverly Hills products specialize in brow perfection, and this makeup line’s philosophy believes that perfection lies in the details. This brow pencil is exactly what you need to keep brows looking neat and tidy. The shimmer formula one side will also help highlight your eyes, and is perfect for that evening “wow” look. The other side is a matte formula perfect for a natural daytime look. You get two pencils in one so you can take your look from day to night in a snap. This creamy brow pencil comes in two color options; one for cool skin tones and the other works for warmer tones.

NYX Eyebrow Push-Up Bra

For starters, who doesn’t love a good push-up bra? This pencil uses the same idea to give your brows and face a youthful, lifted look. The nude pencil helps your eyes look brighter and the colored pencil on the other end helps brows look full and sculpted. This powerful duo will help your brows look groomed, defined and set the perfect frame for your eye makeup. NYX products are very affordable and this one is the best value because you are getting 2 products for the price of 1.

Chella Ivory Lace Highlighter Pencil

This brow pencil comes in a universally flattering tan shade. It blends into the skin and is ideal to blend into the brow bone, conceal discoloration around the eyes and inner corners to brighten. This not only highlights eyes but Chella recommends using this around the edge of lips to lock your favorite shades in place. If you have darker skin you can find a highlighter shad to fit your skin tone. This pencil glides on easily, and is the perfect size to apply with precision and ease.

Clinique Instant Lift For Brows

There are so many things to love about this product. You are getting top quality ingredients at a reasonable cost with Clinique. You never need to worry about irritation or allergic reactions with this solid brand. This is an automatic pencil. All you need to do is turn it; no sharpener required which makes this pencil super user-friendly. It also is dual sided; one side is for your serious natural and effervescent eye looks. The other has a subtle shimmer for instant attractive impact. If the eyes are the windows to the soul, then this is the product to invite the gazer to take a peak.

Revlon Brow Fantasy Pencil

Featuring a defining brow pencil and a tinted gel that adds color (and holds brows in place), this product easily matches its department store counterparts. The end result is natural-looking, polished definition, and the blend-able color and light hold last all day. The gel can be used alone for more casual occasions when you still want your brows to look groomed.

Cover Girl Brow and Eye Makers Pencil

Designed to provide a natural look for eyebrows and eyelids, this pencil gives you soft, neutral, water-resistant color. Due to the hard (as opposed to creamy) formulation, it works much better for the brows than the eyelids (where it can tug and pull). The long-lasting color works to enhance and fill in brows. On the downside, this pencil should be sharpened before each use, which wastes product.

Maybelline Define-A-Brow Eyebrow Pencil

Inside this retractable pencil, you’ll find blend-able, smear-proof, color that fills in and enhances your brows while leaving a natural look. It also comes with a comb to help groom brows and pull color through. The fine point allows for precise application, and the color glides on smoothly without getting clumpy. The one downside is that this pencil runs out fast, so make sure to keep an extra on hand as backup!

Rimmel Professional Eyebrow Pencil

Though this may be a basic brow pencil without any bells or whistles (other than a brow brush attached to the cap), this pencil glides on to fill in sparse spots and accentuate brow color and fullness. It goes on smooth and blends effortlessly without leaving waxy or greasy residue. For the price, it’s a great option. With only three color options, it may be more difficult to find a perfect match.

Almay Brow Defining Pencil

This is a great drugstore eyebrow pencil because you get a lot of bang for your buck. The self-sharpening ultra-fine pencil comes with a built-in brush for grooming, and is formulated with aloe and vitamin E to condition your brows as it enhances their shape and color with precision. It’s easy to apply, and the small tip lets you place color only where needed if you don’t want to shade in the entire brow.

Christian Dior Diorshow Brow Styler Pencil

This waterproof brow pencil turns even a novice into a brow-enhancing expert. The universal shade works on all hair and skin colors, and the ultra-fine tip lets you get down to the root to fill in gaps and lend precise shape and definition to your brows. The retractable pencil means there’s no need to sharpen, and it lasts all day, whether you’re headed to work or working out. The attached spooly brush can be used to groom brows and brush out a heavy-handed application.

Tarte Amazonian Clay Waterproof Brow Pencil

Four times thinner than the average eyebrow pencil, this waterproof pencil is great for filling in sparse spots — and it’s wonderful for adding shape and definition as well. Users love the natural result, and its ability to blend with various eyebrow colors. Formulated with Amazonian clay, this ingredient helps minimize oil around the hair follicles so the pigment stays put. Because it’s retractable and features a built-in brush to get brows in place, it’s easy to use both at home and on the go.

Stila Cosmetics Stay All Day Waterproof Brow Color

More of a brow marker than brow pencil, this waterproof color lasts all day. The formula glides on without pulling or tugging, and the precision felt tip makes it easy to add color just where you need it or enhance your brows’ shape — without clumping or waxy buildup. The liquid is thin enough to be buildable, so you can create the perfect result. This product is available in light and medium shades that blend seamlessly with natural brow colors.

Sephora Collection Retractable Brow Pencil - Waterproof

Designed to add fullness and definition to thin or sparse brows, this waterproof pencil has a great price point and amazing results. Just a few twists of the tube reveals a sharp point that lets you make hair-like strokes, and the comb on the other end makes blending color and grooming brows a breeze. There is a downside, however. If you’re heavy-handed, the pencil runs out fast. Be sure to have an extra on hand so you’re not caught in a pinch.

Smashbox Brow Tech To Go

With a long-lasting waterproof pencil on one end and clear brow fixative gel on the other, this brow duo offers two eyebrow essentials in one tube. The retractable pencil has an angled tip for precise application, and it goes on smooth without leaving waxy residue. It also resists smudging — even if you have oily skin — and the lighter of the two available shades looks natural even on blonde eyebrows. The clear gel keeps longer hairs in place, and helps the color stay put, too.

Tarte Amazonian Clay Waterproof Brow Pencil

Four times thinner than the average eyebrow pencil, this waterproof pencil is great for filling in sparse spots — and it’s wonderful for adding shape and definition as well. Users love the natural result, and its ability to blend with various eyebrow colors. Formulated with Amazonian clay, this ingredient helps minimize oil around the hair follicles so the pigment stays put. Because it’s retractable and features a built-in brush to get brows in place, it’s easy to use both at home and on the go.

Josie Maran Argan Magic Brows Brow Marker + Brow Powder Duo

Offering maximum precision thanks to an ultra-fine marker-like felt tip, few eyebrow pencils allow you to “draw on” individual “hairs” to create the illusion of perfect brows like this one. This long-wearing formula goes a step further by including a coordinating powder that defines the shape and color of the brows, while yielding an extremely natural result. Best of all, this product is free of parabens and artificial fragrance, and it’s cruelty-free.

Lavera Eyebrow Pencil All Brows

This eyebrow pencil features 100% natural ingredients, including organic shea butter and jojoba oil that moisturize skin, condition the hairs, and help it glide on effortlessly. In addition to providing what you need to fill in, shape, and define brows, there’s also a brow comb on the opposite end to help blend color so you get perfectly groomed brows every time. The universal shade means no guessing which color is right for you, and the lack of questionable ingredients means there's no chance of irritation for sensitive skin.

Origins Fill In The Blanks Eyebrow Enhancer

Whether you’re looking to fill in sparse spots or create a dramatically defined effect, this retractable (read: you never have to sharpen) pencil makes it easy. The ultra-thin tip lets you control where you place the color, and the attached spooly brush helps blend and groom unruly brows. It contains palm and vegetable oils for a smooth (not waxy) consistency, and silica to absorb oil and keep color in place. Available in two shades (one for blondes, one for brunettes) the color blends well with your brows for a truly natural result.

Shobha Brow Pencil

Featuring all natural ingredients and long-lasting color, this brow pencil makes no sacrifices in the name of going “green”. Free of parabens and artificial fragrance, it’s versatile enough to fill in gaps or provide major definition. The formula is also water-resistant and buildable, so can you decide how bold you want to go. Because it has a hidden built-in sharpener, you always have a perfect point, even when you’re out and about.

Pixi Beauty Natural Brow Duo

With an angled waterproof eyebrow pencil that never needs to be sharpened on one end and tinted brow fixative gel on the other, this combination product makes it easy to get natural-looking, yet defined brows. The flattering one-shade-fits-all hue can be made darker by layering on extra strokes, and eliminates the chance of picking the wrong color. The soft-hold gel tames unruly hairs without feeling stiff or sticky.

Josie Maran Argan Magic Brows Brow Marker + Brow Powder Duo

Offering maximum precision thanks to an ultra-fine marker-like felt tip, few eyebrow pencils allow you to “draw on” individual “hairs” to create the illusion of perfect brows like this one. This long-wearing formula goes a step further by including a coordinating powder that defines the shape and color of the brows, while yielding an extremely natural result. Best of all, this product is free of parabens and artificial fragrance, and it’s cruelty-free.

Revlon Brow Fantasy Pencil

Featuring a defining brow pencil and a tinted gel that adds color (and holds brows in place), this product easily matches its department store counterparts. The end result is natural-looking, polished definition, and the blend-able color and light hold last all day. The gel can be used alone for more casual occasions when you still want your brows to look groomed.

L'Oreal Brow Stylist Professional

With three eyebrow essentials in one convenient pencil, this stick saves major room in your makeup bag. The powder-based pencil adds subtle definition to the brows (or more drama if you layer it on), while the brush in the cap helps blend color and comb brows into place. But the real standout is the enclosed tweezer that helps you get stray hairs — and perfect-looking brows. One downside: The powder formula doesn’t stand up to sweating.

Smashbox Brow Tech To Go

With a long-lasting waterproof pencil on one end and clear brow fixative gel on the other, this brow duo offers two eyebrow essentials in one tube. The retractable pencil has an angled tip for precise application, and it goes on smooth without leaving waxy residue. It also resists smudging — even if you have oily skin — and the lighter of the two available shades looks natural even on blonde eyebrows. The clear gel keeps longer hairs in place, and helps the color stay put, too.

Anastasia Brow Fix

Sure, this wax-based pencil keeps brows in place and contains vitamin E, aloe, and other ingredients to condition your brows, but it also does a lot more. This pencil can be used alone or over colored brow pencil to help “set” color and keep it in place. It can also be used as an invisible lipliner to prevent lipstick from bleeding. When you use it on your lash line, it transforms any shadow into eyeliner.

MAC Cosmetics MAC Brow Finisher

Designed to help shape the brows and hold them in place, this slim, angled, wax-based pencil leaves brows looking sleek and polished. The twist-up pencil glides on smooth without leaving clumps or a sticky feel, and you may just love the results so much that you skip the colored eyebrow pencil altogether. It’s also great for helping brow color last all day (and night).

Lavera Eyebrow Pencil All Brows

This eyebrow pencil features 100% natural ingredients, including organic shea butter and jojoba oil that moisturize skin, condition the hairs, and help it glide on effortlessly. In addition to providing what you need to fill in, shape, and define brows, there’s also a brow comb on the opposite end to help blend color so you get perfectly groomed brows every time. The universal shade means no guessing which color is right for you, and the lack of questionable ingredients means there's no chance of irritation for sensitive skin.

It Cosmetics Brow Power Universal Brow Pencil

This long-lasting universal brow pencil works well with all skin tones and brow colors, and the oval-shaped tip results in a very natural look. But beyond shaping and defining brows, the gel-like formula also optimizes the look and feel of your brows. Infused with biotin, lecithin, saw palmetto, nettle leaf, green tea, and more, it aims to promote healthy hair follicles to keep brows full. It also comes with a spooly brush to help blend color and create a groomed look.

Too Faced Brow-nie Brow Pencil

This multitasking powder-based eyebrow pencil fills in sparse spots, shapes undefined brows, controls unruly hairs with natural fruit waxes, and conditions each individual hair with cocoa bean. Although you may need to sharpen between applications, the super-pigmented color has the power to last all day — and the attached spooly brush makes blending and grooming a cinch. It goes on smooth without feeling overly waxy, and the pencil itself seems to last and last.

Christian Dior Diorshow Brow Styler Pencil

This waterproof brow pencil turns even a novice into a brow-enhancing expert. The universal shade works on all hair and skin colors, and the ultra-fine tip lets you get down to the root to fill in gaps and lend precise shape and definition to your brows. The retractable pencil means there’s no need to sharpen, and it lasts all day, whether you’re headed to work or working out. The attached spooly brush can be used to groom brows and brush out a heavy-handed application.

Kevyn Aucoin The Precision Brow Pencil - Brunette

This retractable, self-sharpening pencil is ideal for filling in eyebrows, or for more extreme shaping and defining. The texture is the perfect compromise between hard and soft, allowing for easy blending and buildable coverage. The finish is natural with no shine, and application is a cinch. The Precision Brow Pencil comes in three shades (blonde, auburn, and brunette), and has a wand at the other end for natural blending and smoothing.

MAC Eyebrow Pencil

With smooth, long-lasting color, this self-sharpening, self-propelling pencil works wonders for filling in sparse spots, accentuating arches, and enhancing color. It goes on easy thanks to its soft and blend-able formula. With six available shades, its easy to get a natural result. The only downside is that the pencil doesnt retract.

T. LeClerc Eyebrow Pencil

Brow pencil aficionados love this brow pencil because of its powdery (not waxy) formula. This pencil performs best when sharpened before each use. It deposits fine, precise, hair-like lines that fill in sparse spots and add definition. This long-wearing pencil comes with a spooly brush on the end for grooming brows and blending color.

Lancome 'Le Crayon Poudre' Brow Powder Pencil

Available in seven neutral shades that range from blonde to the deepest brown, this powdery pencil offers long-lasting definition and the illusion of fullness for less-than-bold brows. The double-ended pencil features a spooly brush that softens color for a natural result, and the color is easy to blend for an undetectable finish.

Paige Herman-Axel
With almost 15 years experience as a beauty editor, blogger and writer, products are my life! Name it, I've probably tried it, and it's my pleasure to share my finds and experiences with the world at large. From skincare and makeup to haircare and more, I'm up on the latest launches and all the perennial product favorites, so everyone can reap the beauty benefits!
Related
Go to top